For the young child
1. Ignore it. It May Go Away by Itself – the tantrum, not the child.
Pros: There is a lot less energy involved on the parents part in this technique. If it can be arranged to occur at home, and the child is having the tantrum to see how it will go over, testing the waters to see who has emotional control of the house… it can be useful. If caught early, simply moving to another area of the house may work- and when child decides to join in later (sans tantrum) simply look happy to see the child and ignore the past.
Cons: If you are in public other people may not acclimate to the sight and sound of your child’s tantrum like you do. You may be unprepared for the “bad mommy” looks strangers are shooting at you from 4 tables away at the restaurant. Also, if you are reading this, you probably have already tried this and it did not work.
2. Use physical punishment or threaten to do it.
Pros: It may work.
Cons: It may make it worse, or- depending on what kind you have picked…the child abuse people may get called, as it could be illegal. Physical punishment, spanking, slapping, beating… actually may stop a tantrum…but it probably will do so by startling or scaring, not to mention the possibility of hurting, your child – which breeds fear and anger. It may also make the tantrum worse by making your child more angry or hysterical. Roll the dice and find out… Actually the reason this may not be such a great idea is that it does not force your child to get control of their emotions on their own, or make good choices on their own It risks teaching them their parents’ frustration and anger is bigger, badder and stronger than their own out-of-control emotions, so the world is a very scary place indeed. If the tantrum stops, you may not have taught your child what you wanted.
3. Bribe Your Child to Stop
Pros: It May Work
Cons: You have just created a little hostage taker and they will negotiate for bigger and better. So be careful with this one. Now, this is not to say parents are not human. If Sally is in the middle of tantrum stage and you are at the company picnic for your spouse and s/he is up for a Big Promotion and you are in line for XYZ and chatting it up with the boss, and his son Johnny who is also 3 years old and you see the look on Sally’s face that says, this one’s the real winner mom, wait till you hear the “nooooo” that goes with it…. well…. if you have handled all the other tantrums without bribery, quite possibly if you manage a look of genuine desperation and pleading and bend down and whisper in her ear that you will stop at sugar palace and get her whateveryouwanttimes100 if she just behaves sweetly for 5 minutes…. it may work. But, it only works like once in a lifetime and the sheer and utter desperation has to be genuine.
4. The rest of these are mostly from Jim Fay and Foster Cline’s Parenting With Love And Logic (Updated and Expanded Edition)
* Let your child know you understand what they are feeling and you will be happy to speak to her when her voice is as calm as yours. “You really seem mad right now, and we can talk about it when your voice is as calm as mine” (provided your voice is, ummm, calm)
* Use the “uh-oh” technique- “uh-oh, looks like you need some alone time in your quiet spot/thinking spot until you are feeling calmer.” Relocate your child to their room until they are calm, repeat relocation until they are calm. This of course means that you are calm all the way through. If you are in public, the think/quiet spot might be the car… or anywhere the child is not disturbing others.
* “My ears cannot hear you when you are screaming like that, I am happy to listen to a calm voice” If you are at all sarcastic or angry these techniques will not work. The goal of parenting and getting through a tantrum is to teach a child to control their emotion, accept that they do not make all the choices, and make good choices.
* Avoid the tantrum/power struggle if possible- or at least have it on your terms. If you are depleted, run down and in a bad mood, do not pick a fight with a 3 year old. you will not win. If you know that you have 5 errands to do, but that really, Suzette has “that look about her” then, perhaps you would be wise to rest after 2 and quit while you are ahead. Recognize the little signs of pre-tantrum behavior. Give your child two choices- bread or a roll, crayons or bubbles, milk or water…not every choice.
* If you have had a day, and it is one of Those Days, and your family is home and it looks like a Real Winner, shake it up and break the cycle- throw some fun music on that drowns out the tantrum and have everyone else start dancing. Or, have the family throw simultaneous tantrums about their bad days… see whose is best. Again, done without sarcasm, every once in awhile, this may just throw the little tantrummer off course.
Note Of Caution: If you have caused the tantrum by overstimulating your child- for example taking him to the famous mouse-land…. and keeping him there from 9 am to 11pm and sugaring him up, spinning him around and giving in to retail overload…when he is screaming on the way out of the park…. it is not his fault, it is yours. It happens to the best parents… but you bought the tantrum, and it is best just to wait that one out, it will be followed by a crash, and blissful sleep.